HUMAN RELIABILITY DATA BANKS
Modern systems have four basic components: hardware, software, organizational, and human. With the development of new technologies and systems, the hardware and software reliability has increased dramatically during the past decades, while in many cases the human reliability has remained either unchanged or even deteriorated over the same period as the result of complexity of systems. Human interactions are an important factor during the design, installation, production and operation, and maintenance phases of a product or system. The capacity of human beings to make mistakes and errors has been recognized since the beginning of recorded history. The new view on human error is that you can see the human error as the symptom of deeper trouble, in this case, human error is not a cause of failure. Human error is the effect, or symptom, of deeper trouble inside a system. It is not fair, logical and professionally ethical and sound for experts in the field of human factors and safety to say that human is recognized as the cause of as the matter of fact it is the failure of design and operation team and those who were unable to predict and mitigate source of human failure. This paper review was examined and summarized the history, significance, concepts, contributing factors, and all invented analytical methods and procedures in a systematic human reliability assessment (HRA). Furthermore, available human reliability data banks were introduced and elaborated. The challenges and issues in the field of human reliability field were later highlighted and emphasized. Lastly, the expected directions for future works by researchers and practitioners were suggested.
2 Dhillon, B. S., HUMAN ERRORS: A REVIEW, Microelectronics, 1989, Vol. 29, No. 3, pp: 299-304.
3 Dhillon BS. Human reliability with human factors. New York: Pergamon Press, 1986.
4 Dhillon B.S., Maintainability, Maintenance and Reliability for Engineers, Taylor and Francis, 2006.
5 Munger SJ, Smith RW, Payne D. An index of electronic equipment operability: data store. Report No. AIRC43-1/62 RP (29.1). Pittsburgh: American Institute for Research; 1962.
6 Taylor-Adams S. and Kirwan B., Human reliability data Requirements, Disaster Prevention and Management, 1997, Volume 6, Number 5. 1997 pp: 318-335.
7 Kim D. K., Baek D. H. and Yoon W. C., Development and evaluation of a computer-aided system for analyzing human error in railway operations, Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 2010, 95, pp: 87-98.
8 Sheridan, T. B. Telerobotics, automation and human supervisory control. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1992.
9 Meister, D., Human Factors: Theory and Practice, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1976
10 Dhillon BS. Human reliability with human factors. New York: Pergamon Press; 1986.
11 Meister D. The Problem of Human-Initiated Failures, Proceedings of the 8th National Syposium on Reliability and Quality Control, 1962, pp: 234-239, USA
12 Rouse, W. B. and Rouse, S. H. Analysis and classification of human error, 1983.
13 MLTM. Statistics of Korean rail way accidents. Korean Ministry of Land, Transport, and Maritime affairs. Retrieved March30, 2009, from www.mltm.go.krS
14 Trucco, P.; E, Cagno, F. Ruggeri, O. Grande, “A Bayesian Belief Network modeling of organizational factors in risk analysis: A case study in maritime transportation”, Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 2008, 93, pp: 823-834
15 Lasla, K.P. Human Reliability Fundamentals and Issues, KPI Systems, Silver Spring, MaryLand, USA, 2009.
16 Prosek A. Mavko B. RELAP5/MOD3.3 BEST ESTIMATE ANALYSES FOR HUMAN RELIABILITY ANALYSIS, Hindawi Publisbing Corporation, Science and Technology of Nuclear Installations, 2010, vol. 12pages, Article ID 797193.
17 Dhillon, B.S., Human Error Databanks, Microelectronics Reliability, 1990, Vol. 30, No. 5, pp: 963-971
18 Hagen E. W. (Ed.), Human Reliability Analysis, Nucl. Safety, 17 May-June 1976
19 Dhillon, B. S., ON HUMAN RELIABILITY-BIBLIOGRAPHY, Microelectronics Reliability, 1980, Vol. 20, pp: 371-373.
20 Jenab, K. The Lecture Slides for the Course of Advanced Reliability Modeling, Ryerson University, 2009.
21 Dhillon BS. Design reliability: fundamentals and applications. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press; 1999.
22 Swain A. D, Guttman H. E. Handbook of human reliability analysis with emphasis on nuclear power, 1983. plant applications (Sandia National Labs NUREG CR-1278). Washington, DC: Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
23 Swain A.D. and Guttman H. E., Handbook of Human Reliability analysis with emphasis on nuclear power plant applications, Final Report, NUREG/CR-1278, US Nuclear Regulatory Commission, 1983, Washington, DC.
24 Swain, A.D. Human reliability analysis: need, status, trends and limitations. Reliability Engineering and Systems Safety, 1990, 29, pp: 301–313.
25 Barry Kirwan, W. Huw Gibson, Brian Hickling, Human error data collection as a precursor to the development of a human reliability assessment capability in air traffic management, Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 2008,volume 93, issue 2, pp: 217-233.
26 Kirwan B, The validation of three Human Reliability Quantification techniques-THERP, HEART and JHEDI: Part 1-Technique descriptions and validation issues, Applied Ergonomics, 1996, Vol. 27 No. 6.
27 Kirwan B. A guide to practical human reliability assessment. London: Taylor & Francis; 1994.
28 Kirwan B. SAND: safety assessment for new air traffic concept exploration. PSAM 8, New Orleans, May 2006. ISBN: 0-7918-0244-2.
29 Kirwan B, Ainsworth LA, editors. A guide to task analysis. London: Taylor & Francis; 1992.
30 Kletz T. HAZOP, HAZAN. Notes on the Identification and assessment of hazards rugby. Institute of Chemical Engineers; 1974.
31 Shorrock ST, Kirwan B. Development and application of a human error identification tool for air traffic control. Appl Ergon, 2002; 33, pp: 319-36.
32 Shorrock S, Kirwan B, Smith E. Performance prediction in air traffic management: applying human error analysis approaches to new concepts. In: Kirwan B, Rodgers M, Schaefer D, editors. Human factors impacts in air traffic management. Ashgate: Aldershot; 2005.
33 Perrin E, Spouge J. Safety management coping with complexity in air traffic management. In: Kolowrocki K, editor. Advances in safety & reliability. ESREL; 2005. pp: 1531-40.
34 Kirwan B, Rodgers M, Schaefer D, editors. Human factors impacts in air traffic management. Ashgate: Aldershot; 2005. pp: 549 [Chapter 21].
35 Kirwan B. S, Martin B, Rycraft H. Human Error Data Collection and Data Generation, IJQRM, 2007, 7, 4, pp: 34-62.
36 Lee K.W, Tillman F.A, Higgins J. J. A Literature Survey of the Human Reliability Component in a Man-Machine System, IEEE Transactions on Reliability, 1988, VOL. 37, NO.1.
37 Park J, Jung W, Ha J, Shin Y. Analysis of operator’s performance under emergencies using a training simulator of the nuclear power plant, Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 2004, vol. 83, no. 2, pp: 179-186.
38 Swain A. D., “Shortcuts in human reliability analysis”, Generic Techniques in Systems Reliability Assessment, Noordhoff, 1975.
39 Dhillon, B. S., Singh, C., Engineering Reliability: new techniques and applications, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1981.
40 Meister D. Human reliability. In: Muckler FA, editor. Human factors review. Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 1984. pp: 13-53.
41 Blanchard, R.E., Human Performance and Personnel Resource Data Store Design Guidelines, Human Factors, 1975, Vol. 17, pp: 25-34.
42 Meister, D. and Mills, R.C., Development of a Human Performance Reliability and Maintainability Conference, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York, 1972, pp: 425-439.
43 Williams JC. HEART. A proposed method for assessing and reducing human error. In: Proceedings of the ninth‘‘advances in reliability technology’’ symposium, University of Bradford, 1986.
44 Topmiller, D.A., Human Reliability Databank for Nuclear Power Plant Operations: A Review of Existing Human Reliability Data Banks, US Nuclear regulatory commission, Rept. NUREG/CR 2744/1 of 2, 1992.
45 Shapero A., Human Engineering Testing and Malfunction Data Collection in Weapon System Programs, Wright Air Development Division, Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, OH, WADD TR 60-36, Feb. 1960.
46 Rook L.W. Reduction of Human Error in Industrial Production, Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque, NM, Rept. SCTM 93-63 (14), June 1962
47 Svenson O. On expert judgments in safety analyses in the process industries. Reliab Eng Syst Saf, 1989; 25, pp: 219-56.
48 Boring R.L, Lessons Learned on Benchmarking from the International Human Reliability Analysis Empirical Study, Inl: US Department of Energy National Laboratory, Idaho National Laboratory, June 2010.
49 Forester J, Evaluation of human reliability analysis methods against good practices, Final Report, NUREG-1842, US Nuclear Regulatory Commission, 2006, Washington, DC.
50 Kirwan, B., W. Huw Gibson, Brian Hickling, Human error data collection as a precursor to the development of a human reliability assessment capability in air traffic management, Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 2008, 93, pp: 217-233.
51 Askren WB, Regulinski TL. Quantifying human performance for reliability analysis of systems. Hum Factors, 1969; 11(4), pp: 393-6.
52 Swain A.D., "THERP", SC-R-64-1338, Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque, NM, 1964.
53 Swain AD. Some problems in the measurement of human performance in man–machine systems. Hum Factors, 1964; 6:687–700
54 Coburn R. A human performance databank for command control. In: Proceedings of the US Navy human reliability workshop, February 1971.
55 Siegel A I, Wolf J J, Man-Machine Simulation Models, Wiley, 1969.
56 Seaver DA, Stillwell WG. Procedures for using expert judgement to estimate human error probabilities in nuclear power plant operations. NUREG/CR-2743, Washington, DC 20555, 1983.
57 Hunns DM. The method of paired comparisons. In: Green AE, editor. High risk safety technology. Chichester: Wiley, 1982.
58 Embrey DE, Humphreys PC, Rosa EA, Kirwan B, Rea K. SLIMMAUD: An approach to assessing human error probabilities using structured expert judgement. NUREG/CR-3518, US Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC 20555, 1984.
59 Williams JC. A data-based method for assessing and reducing human error to improve operational performance. In: IEEE conference on human factors in power plants, Monterey, CA, 5–9 June 1988. pp: 436-50.
60 Siegel AI, Bartter WD, Wolf JJ, Knee HE, Haas PM. Maintenance personnel performance simulation (MAPPS) model: summary description, NUREG/CR-3626, 1984, vol. 1. USNRC Washington, DC 20555.
61 Hannaman G.W, Spurgin A.J, Lukic Y.. A model for assessing human cognitive reliability in PRA studies [C]. In: IEEE Third Conference on Human Factors in Nuclear Power Plants, 1985.
62 Embrey DE. SHERPA. A systematic human error reduction and prediction approach. Paper presented at the international topical meeting on advances in human factors in nuclear power systems, Knoxville, TN, 1986.
63 Kirwan B. A comparative evaluation of five human reliability assessment techniques. In: Sayers BA, editor Human factors and decision making. London: Elsevier, Health and Safety Executive, 1988. pp: 87-109.
64 Swain AD. Comparative evaluation of methods for human reliability analysis. GRS-81, Gessellschaft fur Reaktorsicherheit (GRS) mbH, Schwertnergasse 1, 5000 Koln 1, Germany, 1989.
65 Kirwan B, Embrey DE, Rea K. The human reliability assessors guide. Report RTS 88/95Q, NCSR, UKAEA, Culcheth, Cheshire, 1988.
66 Kirwan B, Kennedy R, Taylor-Adams S, Lambert B. The validation of three human reliability quantification techniques. THERP, HEART, and JHEDI: Part II—results of validation exercise. Appl Ergon, 1997; 28(1):17-25.
67 Kirwan B. Validation of human reliability assessment techniques: part 1-validation issues. Saf Sci, 1997; 27(1), pp: 25-41.
68 Kirwan B. Validation of human reliability assessment techniques: part 2-validation results. Saf Sci, 1997; 27(1), pp: 43-75.
69 Dolby AJ. A comparison of operator response times predicted by the HCR model with those obtained from simulators. Int J Qual Reliab Manage, 1990; 5, pp: 19-26.
70 Kantowitz B, Fujita Y. Cognitive theory, identifiability, and human reliability analysis. Reliab Eng Syst Saf, 1990; 29(3), pp: 317-28.
71 Dang V, Siu N. Simulating operator cognition for risk analysis: current models and CREWSIM. Paper in PSAM-II proceedings, San Diego, CA, 20–25 March 1994. pp: 066-7-13.
72 Cacciabue PC, Decortis F, Drozdowicz B, Masson M, Nordvik J-P. COSIMO: a cognitive simulation model of human decision making and behaviour in accident management of complex plants. IEEE Trans Syst Man Cybernet, 1992; 22(5), pp: 1058-74.
73 Dougherty EM. Human reliability analysis—where shoudst thou turn? Reliab Eng Syst Saf, 1990; 29(3), pp: 283-99.
74 Hollnagel E. Human reliability analysis: context and control. London: Academic Press; 1993.
75 Gertman DI, Haney LN, Ostrom LT. Evidence of the need to model errors of commission in risk assessments for varied environments. In: PSAM-II proceedings, San Diego, CA, 20–25 March 1994. pp: 005-15-20.
76 Strater O. Evaluation of human reliability on the basis of operational experience. GRS-170. Ko¨ ln, Germany: GRS; 2000 (ISBN:3-931995-37-2).
77 Hollnagel E. Cognitive reliability and error analysis method (CREAM). UK: Elsevier Science Ltd, 1998.
78 Le Bot P. Methodological validation of MERMOS by 160 analyses. In: Proceedings of the International workshop building the new HRA: errors of commission from research to application. NEA/CSNI/R(2002)3. OECD: Issy-les-Moulineaux; 2003
79 Cooper SE, Ramey-Smith AM, Wreathall J, Parry GW, Bley DC, Luckas WJ, et al. A technique for human error analysis (ATHEANA) technical basis and method description. Nureg/CR-6350. US Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC 20555, 1996.
80 Forester J, Bley D, Cooper S, Lois E, Siu N, Kolaczkowski A, et al. Expert elicitation approach for performing ATHEANA quantification. Reliab Eng Syst Saf, 2004, 83(2), pp: 207-20.
81 Gertman, D., Gilmore, W.E. and Ryan, T.G., "Nuclear and Human Reliability: Data Sources and Data Profile", IEEE 4th Conference on Human Factors and Power Plants, 5-9 June, Monterey, CA, 1988.
82 Taylor-Adams ST, Kirwan B. Human reliability data requirements. Int J Qual Reliab Manage, 1995; 12(1), pp: 24-46.
83 Gibson WH, Megaw ED. The implementation of CORE-DATA, a computerised human error probability database. HSE contract research report 245/199. Sheffield: Health and Safety Executive; 1999.
84 Kirwan B, Gibson H, Kennedy R, Edmunds J, Cooksley G, Umbers I. Nuclear action reliability assessment (NARA): a data-based HRA tool. In: Spitzer C, Schmocker U, Dang VN, editors. Probabilistic safety assessment and management 2004. London: Springer; 2004, pp: 1206-11.
85 Basra G, Kirwan B. Collection of offshore human error probability data. Reliab Eng Syst Saf, 1998; 61, pp: 77-93.
86 Cacciabue PC. Modelling and simulation of human behaviour in system control. London: Springer; 1998.
87 Strater O, editor. Human reliability analysis: data issues and errors of commission. Reliab Eng Syst Saf, 2004; 83(2) [special issue].
88 Hollnagel E. CREAM: cognitive reliability error analysis method. Oxford: Elsevier Science Ltd; 1998.
89 Basra G, Gibson H, Kirwan B. Collection of offshore human error probability data: phase 2, volume 1, offshore drilling data. Offshore Technology
Report OTO-98-121. Health & Safety Executive, Merseyside, July 1998.e
90 Ng GAL, Gibson WH, Kirwan B, Siemieniuch CE, Sinclair MA. Development of a process for human reliability assessment in a defence industries context. Contemporary ergonomics 2004. In: Proceedings of the annual conference of the Ergonomics Society, Swansea, April 2004, pp: 465-9.
91 Gibson WH. Personal communication as Manager of the COREDATA Project, 2005.
92 Dhillon B.S., Human and Medical Device Reliability, Handbook of Reliability Engineering, Hoang Pham (Editor), UK: Springer, 2003, Chapter 29, pp: 529-541.
93 Gertman DI, Blackman HS, Human reliability and safety analysis data handbook. New York: JohnWiley and Sons; 1994.
94 Urmston R. Operational performance recording and evaluation data system (OPREDS). Descriptive Brochure, Code 3400. San Diego, CA: Navy Electronics Laboratory Center; November 1971.
95 Hornyak S.J. Effectiveness of Display Subsystems Measurement and Prediction Techniques, Rome Air Development Center, Griffiss Air Force Base, NY, RADC Rept, TR-67-292, Sept., 1967.
96 Aviation Safety Reporting Program. FAA Advisory Circular No. 00-4613; June 1, 1979. Washington, DC: -Federal Aviation Administration (FAA).
97 Topmiller DA, Eckel JS, Kozinsky EJ. Human reliability data bank for nuclear power plant operations: a review of existing human reliability data banks. Report No. NUREG/CR 2744/1; 1982. Available from the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC].
98 Irwin IA, Levitz JJ, Freed AM. Human reliability in the performance of maintenance. Report No. LRP 317/TDR-63-218; Available from the Aerojet-General Corporation, Sacramento, CA. 1964.
99 Dhillon BS. Mechanical reliability: theory, models, and applications. Washington, DC: American Institute of Aeronatics and Astronautics; 1988.
100 Life Sciences Accident and Incident Classification Elements and Factors. AFISC Operating Instruction No. AMISCM-127-6; December 1971. Available from the Department of Air Force,Washington, DC
101 Gibson H, Basra G, Kirwan B. Development of the CORE-DATA database. Safety Reliab J Safety Reliab Soc Manchester, 1999, 19(1), pp: 6-20.
102 Kim, I.S., Human reliability analysis in the man–machine interface design review. Annals of Nuclear Energy 28, 1069–1081; 2001.
103 Mosleh, A., Chang, Y.H., 2004. Model-based human reliability analysis: prospects and requirements. Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 83, pp: 241-253.
104 Klir, J., Yuan, B., Fuzzy Sets and Fuzzy Logic: Theory and Applications. Prentice Hall, New Jersey, 1995.
105 Y.T.XI, W.J.CHEN and Q.G.FANG S.P. HU, HFACS Model Based Data Mining of Human Factors-A Marine Study, Proceedings of the IEEE IEEM, 2010.
106 Hojjati-Emami K, Dhillon B. Jenab K. Methodology and Framework for Development of Effective Human. Reliability Data-Banks in Road Transportation Systems, 4th Joint IAJC/ISAM Joint International Conference, Florida, 2014.
107 Hojjati-Emami K, Dhillon B. Jenab K. The HRA-Based Road Crash Data Methodology for Crash Investigation and Distribution Characteristics of Driver’s Failure Rate, International Journal of Strategic Decision Sciences, IGI Global, USA, 2014.
108 Hojjati-Emami K, Dhillon B. Jenab K. Stochastic Risk Assessment Methodology and Modeling as In-Vehicle Safety Enhancing Tool for Younger Drivers on Roads, Journal of Transportation Safety and Security,Taylor & Francis, USA, 2014.
109 Hojjati-Emami K, Dhillon B. Jenab K. The FTA’s Constrained Methodology in Risk Assessment of Crash and Condition Monitoring for Older Drivers on Roads, Journal of Transportation Safety and Security, 20145(3), pp: 257-272, Taylor & Francis, USA.
110 Hojjati-Emami K, Dhillon B. Jenab K. The Integrative Time-Dependent Modeling of the Reliability and Failure of the Causes of Drivers’ Error leading to Road Accidents, International Journal of Strategic Decision Sciences, 2013, 4(1), pp: 25-39, IGI Global Publisher, USA.
111 Hojjati-Emami K, Dhillon B. Jenab K. The Stochastic & Integrative Prediction Methodology and Modeling for Reliability of Pedestrian Crossing on Roads, Journal of Transportation Safety and Security, 2013 5(3), pp: 257-272, Taylor & Francis, USA.
112 Hojjati-Emami K, Dhillon B. Jenab K. Reliability prediction for the vehicles equipped with advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) and passive safety systems (PSS), International Journal of Industrial Engineering Computations, 2012, 3(5), pp: 731-742, Growing Science Publisher, Canada,.